Why I Hate St. Patrick's Day

Jamie O'Boyle is the Senior Analyst for the Center for Cultural Studies and Analysis and a friend of a friend of mine who has a very valid point about why he dislikes today's National excuse to get drunk. Submitted with his permission is his article. Take the time today to read this and perhaps think first before donning that green hat and pretending to be Irish:

Why I Hate St. Patrick's Day
By Jamie O'Boyle

When I was a child, way back in the 1950s, choosing friends was easy. If they weren’t Irish, Catholic, Democrats, they didn’t get past my grandmother.

I was her only grandson, so I was carried around on a pillow. I’m speaking metaphorically, of course, although with my grandmother you can never be sure. Anyway, “spoiled rotten” is the phrase that springs to mind, and I pretty much had my way on everything. But on one point she stood firm. She was Irish and I was Irish and I wasn’t to have any truck with “foreigners,” which was pretty much everybody whose last name wasn’t prefaced by a vowel.

My grandmother was not born in Ireland. She was from Archibald, Pennsylvania, and being a native-born American was a definite asset to her Irishness. It allowed her to hate the British with a fervor undimmed by the inconvenience of ever having met any.

She could recite the litany of English oppression from the moment the first iron-clad English knights smashed into the lightly-armed Irish warriors like panzers through the Salvation Army. She could call the roll of Irish Martyrs, but she could also quote Yeats and O’Casey, Swift and Synge, Shaw and Wilde. She knew all about the Wild Geese and why a fine French cognac has an Irish name. She knew of the monastery at Clonmacnois, the cultural center of the world in the Fifth Century that produced hauntingly beautiful illuminated manuscripts in an age when the Britons thought ink was for painting their arses blue. She never set foot in Ireland until my aunt gave her a gift of the Catholic version of a double-header—a two-week tour that included Ireland and the Vatican. She was in her 70s by then, and the day she arrived in Dublin someone set off a dynamite charge that blew the statue of Lord Nelson off his pillar on O’Connell Street.

We always wondered about that.

You would assume from all this that I grew up knowing a lot about Ireland. In fact, I grew into a typical American teenager. In other words, I never listened to a word she said. All I knew about Ireland was a vague impression that it was supposed to be green.

With my usual stellar sense of timing, I arrived in Ireland on July 12, 1969. This is comparable to visiting Vietnam in 1968 because you heard that the Tet celebration was kind of colorful. Within a month my family picked up the paper to read “AMERICAN SHOT TWICE IN ULSTER.” This was typical yellow journalism; the bullets came nowhere near my Ulster. I lived through the riots in Bogside and Belfast, the arrival of the British Army, the bombings, the rise of the Provisional IRA, and the first year of the guerilla war, which is still being fought by children who weren’t even born when I left.

It should have been horrible. It wasn’t. I planned to stay for two weeks. I stayed for two years.

There is something about Ireland that can’t be summed up in words. God knows, the Irish have tried. Ireland is green; a brilliant shade of emerald that exists nowhere else in the world, a green so alive it turns jet black when the clouds hide the sun. There’s something in the earth and the people that wants to make you put down roots and soak it up.

There is an instant, just at dawn, when everything turns soft and indistinct and you feel the slightest breeze would scatter the island like a mist. The dreary Victorian cities sparkle for a moment and the countryside seems to hold its breath. If you don’t believe in magic, you’ve never been to Ireland.

I didn’t want to leave, but the American Embassy gets touchy when you get involved in other people’s wars without asking their permission. Don’t bother asking, you won’t get it.

This is all my way of saying that I hate St. Patrick’s Day.

Americans are unusually conscious of their ethnic heritage. We celebrate Columbus Day as an Italian festival, the Germans hold a Von Steuben Day Parade, the Poles march for Kosciuszko and Copernicus, the Mexicans celebrate Cinco de Mayo. There isn’t an ethnic group in the country that doesn’t sponsor a folk festival celebrating the unique and entertaining qualities of their homeland. So what do Irish-Americans do to commemorate a heritage that stretches back to the mists of time?

They drink green beer.

This may come as a shock, but in Ireland, St. Patrick’s Day is a religious holiday. It is not customary to celebrate the patron saint by wearing a paper hat and drinking green beer until you throw up on your shoes. It is also considered a breach of etiquette to throw up on someone else’s shoes, particularly if that someone is standing in them at the time.

Face it folks, Jews don’t have a holiday on which they wear plastic big noses and stuff their pockets with play money and African-Americans don’t sponsor a tap dancing and watermelon festival. So why do the Irish take their worst stereotypes, set them to music, and dance to them? I don’t know what Irish-Americans think they are doing on St. Patrick’s Day, but it has nothing to do with Ireland.

If you feel the need to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day, here are a few helpful pointers.

It’s OK to wear a touch of emerald on March 17th. They don’t do it in Ireland but there’s no harm in showing a bit of ethnic pride. It isn’t mandatory, however, particularly if the only greens in your wardrobe are avocado, lime, Nile, moss, sage, pea, day-glo, or what Joyce described as “snot green.” Do not, under any circumstances, wear every green item you possess. People will not think you are Irish. They will think you are a teenage alien life form from the planet Zook whose mother allowed it to pick out its own clothes.

The gentleman’s name was St. Patrick, not St. Patty or St. Paddy. Patty is the name of a dental hygienist. Paddys are where you grow rice. St. Patrick was an Italian who was brought to Ireland by the Vikings. He brought Christianity to the island and drove out the snakes with his staff. The names of the staff, which did the actual work, are unknown. You should ignore that last bit. I put it in as a St. Patrick’s Day gift to my colleague, Susan McAninley, whose sense of humor runs in that direction.

People who wear buttons which read “Kiss Me, I’m Irish” inevitably aren’t. Don’t kiss them; you don’t know where they’ve been.

“Toora, loora, loora” is not an Irish lullaby. It’s the sound of Bing Crosby clearing his throat. Likewise, “Who put the overalls in Mrs. Murphy’s chowder?” is not an Irish song. True Irish music is uplifting, exciting, poignant, and melancholy, very often in the same song. Don’t try to sing along. Shut up and listen.

“Faith and begorrah” is not an Irish expression. It may be the name of an Anglo-Irish law firm.

Don’t wear a trenchcoat and hint darkly that you are in the IRA. The quiet little man sitting in the corner—the one with the cloth cap, bright birdlike eyes, and hands gnarled by arthritis he picked up in a British prison camp may take offense. You don’t want to piss him off. Trust me on this.

If you feel a sudden suicidal urge to tell and Irish joke, you may escape with only flesh wounds if you refrain from telling it in a terrible Barry Fitzgerald accent. There are many regional accents in Ireland, and none of them sound like Barry Fitzgerald. The man was an actor. It was his business to exaggerate for effect. All Irishmen do not sound like Fitzgerald any more that all people from Missouri sound like Vincent price.

The phrase “It’s a great day for the Irish” is true. Every day is a great day for the Irish.


Claire said...

st patrick was welsh, he was kidnapped and not by vikings by celts.

Claire said...

oh and I'm Irish and really liked your post, but don't stress about the little things, sure St pattys day is really annoying and when you have to explain to Americans that you actually have cars and televisions can be frustrating. I think its wonderful that even so it might be a bit stereotypical that the whole world celebrates our country is an honour that no other country gets. This St.Patricks day I wore green, watched the parade, went to be pub and danced the night away and had a wonderful time.

Anonymous said...

st patrick was from britain, and his family was roman catholic, not welsh..get your facts straight please....and the facts about driving away the snakes. never happened thats a folklore ...he converted the irish from pagans to christian's then he was ordained..for doing so..

Anonymous said...

See Pope Celestine I, Anony: 11:06 A.M. And are you an archeologist? If not, you should apply due to the dearth of facts from the 5th Century.

Hollywood Dump on Facebook

In addition to the articles we post here, we also link to stories we think are interesting and post them to our Facebook page. If you're on FB, become a fan!